"Our intention is to discuss the media and its impact on this and other similar cases, the reality of the penal system in Brazil, and rehabilitation."
"Director" Lygia M. Barbosa
Source: https://www.netflix.com/tudum/pt-br/artigos/suzane-von-richthofen-o-que-o-tempo-nao-apaga-entrevista-com-lygia-m-barbosa
In a morally healthy country, the justice system should operate based on the principle of proportionality—where the greater the severity of the crime committed, the harsher the punishment. This is justice in its purest form—the very same guiding principle we tend to apply in our own daily interactions (provided we aren't moral idiots). However, Brazil—the country in question—has never been a model of moral soundness; and in these first few decades of the 21st century, it has layered on even more institutionalized immorality, albeit under a different veneer than before. While it was once the old "elites"—including the Church—that dictated the prevailing moral code, our own brand of "modernity" (a uniquely Brazilian variety, influenced by the importation of perversities from abroad) has seen the rise of a "new" orthodoxy. This orthodoxy positions itself in total opposition to the cultural traditionalism of the "past." This new moral "elite"—and the code it upholds—defines itself as "progressive," claiming to possess the wisdom of the Enlightenment. It views itself as the heir to those initial revolutionary sparks that began to dismantle the once-absolute social and cultural foundations—a process that first took hold in the United Kingdom and France during the 17th and 18th centuries.
One of the key points of contention between this "new" code and the "old" one concerns the administration of "justice." Under the "old" code, justice was—and in some ways still is—applied with a degree of proportionality (though, admittedly, this could be—and can still be—obscured or subverted by power, social prestige, or wealth). The "new" code, driven largely by a contrarian impulse, breaks sharply with this logic. Here, the proportionality of the crime is relegated to the background—treated almost as an irrelevant detail—while the primary focus shifts to the social rehabilitation of the offender. In short, this "Jacobin morality" prioritizes the rehabilitation of the criminal over their punishment within the judicial process. Furthermore, this belief system gains additional moral layers depending on the individual’s social status or identity; certain identities or circumstances may render an offender more "excusable" in the eyes of these self-appointed arbiters of a "sociological morality"—a framework they claim is more "scientific" than the traditional religious approach to judging society and the individual. Under this moral paradigm, the victim—especially if... ...fully consummated as such, it matters little: the victim’s memory is tacitly eclipsed by the continued existence of the person who took their life. Yet, there is no need for a definitive, fatal conclusion; it suffices that the perpetrator of a crime—especially one that is barbaric or heinous—remains alive, and their rights continue to be treated as paramount. After all, according to this morality, "everyone deserves a second chance"—provided, of course, that they are still among the living and fit the mold of those deemed "ideologically absolvable."
As a result of decades of the progressive infiltration of traditional institutions by leftist militants and their activism, the old principle of proportionality has been supplanted by a focus on the "rehabilitation" of criminals—a framework in which the perpetrator, rather than the victim, receives the lion's share of attention. It was only a matter of time before films and documentaries that relativize specific, high-profile cases of heinous crimes became commonplace. And so, in 2026, we see a new documentary from the infamous Netflix Brazil—not merely revisiting a case already exhaustively covered (the 2002 cold-blooded murder of an affluent São Paulo couple, orchestrated by their own daughter), but centering on the mastermind behind this barbaric act. She was released after serving only a few years, having benefited from her social standing and a record of "good behavior" while incarcerated—a crime so cruel it should have warranted, at the very least, a life sentence. Beyond the sheer absurdity of giving a platform to this murderess—ostensibly to share her "version of events"—it has also come to light that she received a generous fee of half a million reais for her participation. This is a slap in the face to millions of hardworking Brazilians—people often exploited by greedy employers and crushed by a government whose unbridled appetite for revenue leads it to tax everything, down to our very souls. While conservative forces certainly carry a historical legacy—and a present—marred by wars, scientific obscurantism, and social injustice, those on the left of the political-ideological spectrum (who began to emerge in the pre-revolutionary contexts alluded to above) have consistently demonstrated that their primary goal is not the genuine emancipation of oppressed groups, but rather the exploitation of these groups as stepping stones to attain and perpetuate their own power. One of the methods employed is the relativization of morality—a corrupt society, unable to distinguish right from wrong, is more easily controlled. This same method is further reinforced by the society itself, reflecting its own duplicitous nature—much like a wolf in sheep’s clothing (or a fox in sheep’s clothing) that convinces the farm animals to pity it, even as it reveals a complete lack of basic dignity. Therefore, this is not merely about a specific individual like "Suzane," nor about a form of self-destructive "kindness" that preaches compassion even for those who have shown they do not deserve it. Rather, it is a preemptive strategy: criminals—occupying positions of power and authority over the lives of others—use carefully crafted rhetoric to dismantle the very mechanisms a society has established to curb certain types or levels of crime. These same individuals—hypocritical architects of a supposedly "superior" morality—simultaneously display a shameless desire to criminalize thought and free expression within the public sphere. As a non-religious man, I do not typically rely on non-secular concepts to explain or understand the world of degeneration and inversion in which we live; yet, without needing to invoke metaphysical forces, it is clear that the modern Left has, in practice, become a form of Satanism—inverting many ancestral values that, however imperfect, at least sought to follow a logical thread of balance, truth, and coherence. The cultural erosion of the distinction between right and wrong—and between reality and fiction—promoted primarily by this "identity-politics" Left from within positions of power, is the fundamental reason why, today, cold-blooded murderers and their crimes are celebrated in the media. There is no genuine possibility of "character rehabilitation"—the very foundation upon which the concept of resocialization is supposedly built.
Nenhum comentário:
Postar um comentário