Is she a cold, narcissistic mother who cares nothing for her two daughters—or is she someone, perhaps like you or me, who simply chose to live her own life rather than "sacrifice" it?
In both the arts and common sense, goodness has long been linked to sacrifice or self-abnegation.
"The kindest person is one capable of giving their own life to save another human being or living creature."
This is widely regarded as the ultimate demonstration of goodness...
I don’t necessarily consider this entirely wrong—though I have written pieces critiquing this association between goodness and self-sacrifice, as it carries both pros and cons. Such an association is often linked to naivety, or a purity of character so extreme that it blinds one to the true nature of evil—effectively turning a virtue into a flaw, a form of weakness. At times, what appears to be a genuine altruistic inclination is actually a disguised form of moral narcissism. In *Autumn Sonata*—yet another indisputable masterpiece by the brilliant Swedish director Ingmar Bergman—this fundamental moral conflict takes center stage, pitting the kind, sensitive daughter (Eva) against her cold, narcissistic mother (Charlotte).
*Autumn Sonata*: Before and After Maturity (my take)
Charlotte (Ingrid Bergman) is an accomplished and sophisticated concert pianist who decides to pay a multi-day visit to her eldest daughter, who lives in seclusion with her husband (Halvar Björk) amidst the Norwegian mountains. Things seem to unfold in a seemingly normal fashion, until Eva (Liv Ullmann) finally unburdens herself regarding her relationship with her mother—confronting her with the neuroses, complexes, and traumas inflicted by the matriarch’s overwhelming narcissism. Furthermore, there is the younger daughter, Helena (Lena Nyman), who suffers from a progressive neurological condition; she lives in the same house as her sister, who brought her home from an institution—a development that comes as an unpleasant surprise to Charlotte, who had long avoided witnessing the increasingly degenerative state of her youngest child. At this point, we have our "heroines" and our "villain"—and this is how most people (likely including you, the reader, just as it was for me) tend to analyze and interpret the situation: inevitably condemning the mother while canonizing the daughters. Yet, it is precisely when we fail to explore every perspective within a given context—choosing instead to favor those that best align with our own sense of morality—that we reduce a complex issue to a simplistic "good guy versus bad guy" dynamic. Not that every human situation is like this, of course; there are certainly cases where roles are more clearly defined. However, in this case—since the mother did not, strictly speaking, do anything truly terrible to her daughters (she placed her ill daughter in an institution, believing she could not care for her on her own; she remained distant from the other daughter; as she went on to live her own life—much as she always had—by focusing on her work and social life)—I see no reason to condemn her so harshly. While there may be morally "nobler" paths one could take—such as dedicating one’s life to the care of a vulnerable person—Charlotte did what I believe many people in her position would have done. I suspect I might have done the same, and perhaps you, the reader, might have as well. Just imagine: without a prestigious career or the financial means that come with it, having to devote yourself, body and soul, to a completely dependent human being—with little to no outside help—to the point where you can no longer enjoy even a shred of your own life. It is all too easy to pass judgment without truly putting oneself in the shoes of those involved—and I mean not only the daughters, but the mother as well. Moral or emotional maturity lies not merely in identifying what is "right" or "wrong"—or, more realistically, what is "more right" or "more wrong" along a broader spectrum—but also in the ability to perceive or place oneself within the complex circumstances of others, considering every perspective before labeling someone’s behavior in a purely, simplistic, black-and-white manner. Even if Charlotte’s choices were not "right," it is difficult to condemn her outright; when faced with the choice between sacrificing oneself for another or seeking to maximize one’s own comfort—especially in a situation like this, or others much like it—it is, in fact, quite common for people to choose the latter. Even if she is a narcissist—and, in that sense, immature—it does not necessarily mean she is immature in every respect, including in her personal choices; after all, it is not always possible to establish rigid moral definitions. She did what she believed to be the "right" thing: she did not abandon her ill daughter—placing her instead in the care of a specialized institution—nor did she pursue her other daughter, who chose her own path. Charlotte, for her part, was unwilling to give up the career and the life she had always cherished. As for Eva, while her mother may have left her with deep-seated emotional scars, Eva’s own inherent fragility made it difficult for her to heal from them. It is also worth noting that Charlotte recognized the unhappy atmosphere in Eva’s home—where both Eva and her husband, trapped in perpetual mourning, were unable to accept or cope with the loss of their only child. Charlotte’s own sunny, optimistic, and pragmatic personality—though capable of causing harm—also carries a positive aspect: she refuses to be crushed by the sorrows that life, sooner or later, inevitably brings. In conclusion, while Charlotte’s actions toward her two daughters may seem cold for a mother, it would be hypocritical to accuse her of total abandonment or neglect. It is far easier to cast judgment from the outside—especially for those who have never experienced the daily, sacrificial commitment required by such a situation, or who lack the specific character traits suited to it. If one were truly in this mother’s position—or any similar situation—it would not be so simple to pass judgment, particularly when faced with the prospect of dedicating one’s entire existence to the care of a highly dependent person, effectively sacrificing one’s own life, dreams, and desires.
It is important to emphasize that I do not fully endorse the actions of the film’s central character—nor, by extension, similar actions in real-life situations. At the same time, I have made it clear that judging her harshly strikes me as overly simplistic and potentially hypocritical. As has been noted several times here, many people might well make similar choices if placed in the same situation—and, furthermore, they would not necessarily be "wrong" to do so. It is akin to a "Sophie’s Choice"—a complex dilemma where no available option is entirely satisfactory, nor is any one choice definitively better than the others. Consider that, in the film, had Charlotte devoted herself solely to her family until old age—forsaking her professional and social life—she might well have ended up a bitter, regretful woman...
*It is possible to reconcile altruism with personal well-being.